Disclosure: As an eBay Partner, ScottyIndex may be compensated when you buy through links on this site.
15 My Girl listings live on eBay right now, starting at $718. Real prices from the ScottyIndex price guide, updated daily.
A live selection of the 15 My Girl listings currently on eBay, lowest price first. Click any card to view and buy on eBay.
My Girl 2014 Putter 33 Inch Right
Studio Design 5 Putter RH 34" My Girl Style Custom Shop
Limited Edition My Girl Exclusive Putter – Premium High-Quality
Limited 2010 My Girl Pretty in Pink 33in Putter- Gray Pistolero
2024 My Girl Limited Hello Sunshine Catalina Putter 33" RH
Rare My Girl Limited Edition Putter that is black and blue
2025 MyGirl Putter
2025 Mygirl putter
My Girl Mallet Putter RH Steel Shaft Pink/Silver.
Limited Edition My Girl 2024 Putter - NEW And IN BAG 34” Rare
NEW 2023 My Girl XOXO Limited Edition Putter 34in RH RARE Mallet
My Girl 2002 First Generation Newport Mil-Spec Limited Putter
2007 My Girl CIRCA ‘62 No. 6 LE Putter 33 in.
*NEW* Limited 2008 My Girl Fleur De Lis 33in Putter| Cotton Candy
2018 My Girl Putter
Used My Girl putters sell for a median of $1,300, with most changing hands between $1,249 and $1,448. Based on 53 confirmed eBay sales. Check this before you buy so you know a fair price when you see one.
See the full My Girl value guideAsking prices on live listings run higher than what My Girl putters actually sell for. Use the median and typical range above as your anchor, and treat anything near or below the median in good condition as a strong buy.
Face wear, sole scratches, and paint-fill loss all move the price. A "mint" or "like new" My Girl commands the top of the range; bag chatter and a worn face sit near the bottom. Zoom in on every photo and check the listed condition against what you see.
An original matching headcover adds real value and is the first thing collectors look for. A My Girl sold without its cover, or with a generic replacement, should cost less. Confirm the cover, shaft band, and grip match the model and year.
Length (33–35"), dexterity, and head weight all affect feel. A used My Girl is sold as-is, so buy the spec you actually play. Filter the live listings by length and dexterity rather than planning to re-shaft, which erodes both feel and resale value.
Used Scotty Cameron My Girl putters sell for a median of $1,300, with most transacting between $1,249 and $1,448, based on 53 confirmed eBay sales. Condition, original headcover, dexterity, and length all move the price within that range. Live asking prices run higher than sold prices, so use the median as your benchmark.
eBay has the deepest and most active supply of used My Girl putters, which is why the listings on this page link straight there. Buying on eBay also gives you buyer protection and verified seller feedback. ScottyIndex aggregates those live listings and pairs them with real sold-price data so you can tell a fair deal from an overpriced one before you commit.
Check the milling and stamping quality, the shaft band and grip branding, and the headcover against known photos of the My Girl. Be cautious of prices well below the typical range, vague photos, or sellers who avoid showing the sole and face. Buying from established eBay sellers with strong feedback and clear, original photos is the safest path.
A used My Girl in good condition bought near or below the $1,300 median is usually a sound buy. Scotty Cameron putters hold value well, so a fairly priced used example carries low downside if you ever resell. Overpaying versus the sold-price range is the main risk, which is exactly what the price data on this page helps you avoid.
Browse every Scotty Cameron putter for sale, or open the full price guide.