Look up what your putter sells for, then follow the playbook to price and list it. Real eBay values, no signups, updated daily.
What buyers actually pay across thousands of confirmed sales.
What retailers and trade-in services typically pay for the same putter.
Clean listings sell faster and at higher prices. These are the moves that consistently push a Scotty Cameron above the typical range.
Eight or more shots: sole, face, back cavity, neck, shaft band, grip, headcover (front and back), and any tour-issue stamps or COA. Listings with sharp natural-light photos clear 15-25 percent above text-only listings on the same model.
A matching factory headcover is the single biggest factor outside the head condition. Without it, you'll see a 10-20 percent discount applied. With a tour or limited cover, you can clear above the typical range.
Set Buy It Now around the 60th to 75th percentile of recent sales for your exact model. Buyers comparing across listings will check completed sales, so being competitive but not under-priced gets you the most without sitting unsold.
Include model, year if known, length, dexterity, and condition. "Scotty Cameron Newport 2 2014 35 inch RH Putter w/ Headcover" outperforms "Scotty Cameron Putter For Sale" because buyers search with all those words.
For standard retail models, Buy It Now or Best Offer pulls 5-15 percent more than auctions. Auctions work for tour-issue, Circle T, and other rare models where bidding war energy actually drives the price up.
Sky marks, paint chips, shaft band scratches, regripping. Clear disclosure prevents returns and negative feedback. eBay buyer protection favors the buyer, so a return on a transparently described putter is rare while one on a glossed-over flaw is automatic.
Use the value lookup above to see the median used eBay sale price for your specific model. Most standard retail models in clean used condition sell for 50 to 70 percent of new retail. Limited Masters releases, tour-issue, and Circle T builds command much higher prices, often above original retail.
eBay almost always pays more, typically 60 to 80 percent above what a retailer or trade-in service offers. Trade-in is faster and easier but you're effectively paying the retailer 30 to 40 percent of the value for the convenience. The exception is condition-issue putters: trade-in services sometimes accept putters that would underperform on eBay due to face damage or missing parts.
Specialty putter resellers (Cool Clubs, GolfWRX classifieds, dedicated forums like Scotty Cameron collectors), local golf shops with consignment programs, and Facebook Marketplace. Forums and resellers will pay more for rare and tour-issue putters because they have specialty buyer networks. eBay remains the deepest market for standard retail models.
In order: face damage or deep sky marks, missing original headcover, custom paint fill or shaft swaps, regripping, and excessive sole wear. A clean head with the matching factory cover holds 90 percent of its value. A modified or face-damaged putter can trade 30 to 40 percent below the median.
Usually no. A matching factory cover lifts the putter price by 10 to 20 percent, more than you would clear selling the cover alone. The exception is rare tour-issue or limited covers that have collector value independent of the head. Those can clear $200 to $1,000+ on their own.
Standard retail models in clean condition sell within 3 to 14 days at fair prices. Limited and tour-issue models go faster, often within 24 hours, because collectors are watching new listings. Mispriced or flawed listings can sit for months. Set the price right and the listing finds a buyer quickly.
Median price, typical range, and recent comparable sales for your exact model. Free, instant, no signup.
Look up your model