Disclosure: As an eBay Partner, ScottyIndex may be compensated when you buy through links on this site.
Real prices for pre-owned Scotty Cameron putters on eBay. Live listings, recent sale benchmarks, and what to check before you buy.
Used Scotty Cameron putters trade in a wide band on eBay. Standard retail models in good condition sit in the few-hundred-dollar range, while limited Masters releases, vintage prototypes, and tour-issue Circle T builds clear thousands. The price you should expect to pay depends mostly on the model family, the year, and how clean the head is.
Most recently listed used putters on eBay. Click any card to view the full eBay listing.
Circle T Putter GoLo w/HC *Made for Cam Smith at 2012 US Amateur*
TeI3 Newport 2- 35 Inches
FUTURA 5S 35 1/2 Inch Putter RH
Select Newport 2 Blade Putter RH Steel Shaft VERY CLEAN! 34in
Putter | Special Select Flowback 5 Excellent Condition 32" w/HC
Futura Putter 33in RH
Studio Style Newport 2 Putter 34 Inches Excellent
THE ART OF PUTTING Oilcan NEWPORT 35in Putter RH With H/C
California SONOMA 34 inches Right Handed
Phantom X 7.5 2019 Putter PT 34 in Original Steel Shaft RH
select SQUAREBACK 1st/500 34in Putter USED JP
Phantom 11R OC Onset Center Shaft Putter 34" Right Hand
Putter
Champions Choice Newport Button Back Blade Putter RH
Phantom X (2021) 11.5 Putter 34" RH
2007 TERYLLIUM TEN NEWPORT TWO 34 inches Right Handed Rare
Used Scotty Camerons are generally a safe buy. The brand has a strong resale floor and a deep enthusiast community. The traps are around condition, provenance on tour-issue claims, and overpaying when sellers anchor to retail.
Scotty milled faces show every range session. Light surface scratches are normal on a putter that has been used. Deep gouges, dents around the sweet spot, or heavy bag chatter on the topline can hurt resale and may indicate a putter that has been gamed hard.
A used Scotty should ship with its original headcover. Mismatched covers are a yellow flag. Serial numbers on the bumper or sole tie the head to a specific era and run. If a seller cannot show clear photos of the serial, ask before bidding.
Real Circle T and tour-only putters come with a Certificate of Authenticity from Cameron when they leave the tour department. A used Circle T listing without a COA, paperwork, or clear sole and back stamps should be treated with caution. Forgeries exist.
Many used putters have been re-shafted, re-gripped, or weight-adjusted. None of these are red flags on their own, but they affect resale value. A standard-length factory build with the original grip generally carries a small premium over a customized one.
Before you buy, search the model on the homepage filter and look at the last 90 days of sold prices for that exact model. If the asking price is more than 20% above the recent sold median, it is overpriced. If it is meaningfully below, double-check the photos and the seller history.
Generally yes. The brand has one of the strongest resale floors in golf. A standard retail Newport 2 in good used condition typically trades $400 to $700, which is roughly half of new retail, with the same milled-feel head and tight tolerances. As long as the head is clean and the face has no major damage, used is the value play.
It depends on the model and the year. Standard retail putters in clean used condition usually sit between $250 and $700. Newer models like Phantom X and Super Select trade higher, often $500 to $900 used. Vintage California series and Studio Select can go either way depending on condition. Limited Masters releases, prototypes, and Circle T builds are a separate market and can clear thousands.
Look at the milling on the face — Scotty faces are precisely milled with consistent line work. Check the sole stamps, the bumper serial, and the back cavity stamps for clean letterforms. A real Scotty ships with its original headcover and any tour-issue claim should have a Certificate of Authenticity. If photos are blurry on the serial or the seller refuses to show clear shots, walk away.
Newport and Newport 2 are the most-traded used Scotty Camerons on eBay by a wide margin. The Newport 2 is the model Tiger Woods has gamed for most of his career and is the default option for buyers coming from a different brand. Phantom X and Squareback follow next.
They should. Every Scotty Cameron putter ships from the factory with a model-specific headcover, and a used listing without one is unusual. Mismatched headcovers are a yellow flag — sometimes innocent (the seller swapped covers between putters) and sometimes a sign the putter was scavenged or the cover was sold separately for value.
eBay is the deepest market with the most price transparency, which is why every listing on this page is from eBay. Prices reflect what buyers and sellers are agreeing to in real time. Specialty putter resellers and tour shops carry curated inventory at higher prices, and Scotty Cameron does not sell directly used.
Filter by model, price, dexterity, and condition. Live prices on every model from real eBay listings.
Open the price guide