Disclosure: As an eBay Partner, ScottyIndex may be compensated when you buy through links on this site.
What used Phantom 9.5 putters actually sell for on eBay, based on 342 confirmed sales.
Share this value as an image on Reddit, Twitter, Instagram.
Each option shows the count of matching used sales in our data. Combinations under 10 sales are flagged as limited data.
Confirmed eBay sales, most recent first. Click any sale to view the original listing.
A used Scotty Cameron Phantom 9.5 typically sells for around $540 on eBay. The middle 50% of recent sales fall between $350 to $550. Outliers ranged from $320 on the low end to $605 for the cleanest examples or rarer variants. The exact price for your putter depends on condition, the original headcover being included, and any aftermarket modifications.
Generally yes. The Phantom 9.5 has an active resale market with 25 confirmed sales tracked in our database, which is enough liquidity to set a fair price quickly. As long as the head is clean and the face has no major damage, used represents the value play over buying new.
In order of impact: face damage or deep sky marks, missing original headcover, custom paint fill or shaft swaps, missing certificate of authenticity for tour-issue models, and excessive sole wear. A clean head with the matching factory cover holds 90% of its value. A heavily worn or modified putter can trade 30 to 40 percent below the median.
The value is the median sale price across every confirmed used eBay sale of the Phantom 9.5 in our database. 25 sales went into this number. The data updates daily as new sales close. Listings under $50 (parts only) and over $5,000 (suspected tour-issue or scam listings) are filtered out so the median reflects genuine retail-grade transactions.
Browse every Scotty Cameron value page or open the full price guide.